Why Israeli Settlers Are Moving Past Netanyahu Toward the Far Right

Why Israeli Settlers Are Moving Past Netanyahu Toward the Far Right

Benjamin Netanyahu spent decades building his brand as Israel's indispensable security hawk. Yet when election day rolls around, a growing share of Israeli settlers aren't checking the box for his Likud party anymore. They're looking straight past him to figures like Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben-Gvir.

It's a massive shift. And if you want to understand modern Israeli politics, you can't ignore it.

For years, the conventional wisdom in Washington and Jerusalem was simple. Settlers needed Netanyahu, and Netanyahu needed settlers. That transactional marriage kept the right-wing bloc glued together through multiple coalition crises, indictments, and five elections in under four years. But on the ground in the West Bank—or Judea and Samaria, as residents there call it—the patience has worn thin. Many voters in these communities view the veteran prime minister as someone who talks tough in English and Hebrew while freezing construction behind closed doors whenever American pressure ramps up.

They want action, not rhetoric.

The Erosion of Trust in Likud

You have to look at the track record to see why the disillusionment set in. Take the 2009 settlement construction freeze. Netanyahu agreed to a 10-month moratorium on new housing starts in the West Bank to appease the Obama administration. Settlers never forgot that. Even though building eventually resumed, the freeze proved to hardline voters that Netanyahu was fundamentally pragmatic—and therefore willing to compromise on their core ideological territory when geopolitical heat got too intense.

Then came the Abraham Accords in 2020. While much of the world celebrated normalization deals with the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain, the price tag for Netanyahu was shelving his much-hyped plan to apply Israeli sovereignty—effectively annexation—to parts of the West Bank. Leaders of the Yesha Council, the umbrella organization representing municipal councils of Jewish settlements, felt blindsided. They had campaigned on sovereignty. They had printed maps. Suddenly, the promise vanished overnight.

Trust breaks fast in politics. Once settlers realized Netanyahu viewed their land as a bargaining chip rather than an untouchable birthright, the search for a real ideological champion began in earnest.

Enter Smotrich and Ben-Gvir

Nature abhors a vacuum, and Israeli politics abhors an unrepresented constituency. Step forward Bezalel Smotrich, head of the Religious Zionist Party, and Itamar Ben-Gvir, leader of Otzma Yehudit (Jewish Power).

Unlike Netanyahu, who grew up in secular, intellectual circles in Jerusalem and Philadelphia, Smotrich is one of them. He lives in Kedumim, a settlement in the northern West Bank, and previously lived in an unauthorized outpost. When he talks about expanding infrastructure, legalizing wildcat outposts, or dismantling the Palestinian Authority's civil governance, he isn't reading off a focus-grouped talking point. He's articulating the exact worldview of the movement's ideological vanguard.

Ben-Gvir, who lives in Kiryat Arba on the outskirts of Hebron, brings a different kind of appeal. While Smotrich speaks to the institutional, bureaucratic side of the settlement enterprise, Ben-Gvir taps into raw frustration over personal security.

Drive down Route 60, the main north-south artery running through the West Bank, and you'll understand why security dominates every dinner-table conversation. Stone-throwing, Molotov cocktails, and fatal shooting attacks have turned daily commutes into high-stress calculations. For voters worried about getting their kids home from school safely, Netanyahu's cautious military containment felt inadequate. Ben-Gvir promised aggressive policing, looser rules of engagement for soldiers, and immediate retaliation.

Honestly, it's not hard to see why that message lands. When people feel physically unsafe, nuanced deterrence theories lose out to blunt force every single time.

What Most People Get Wrong About the Settler Vote

Outside observers often treat the roughly 500,000 Israelis living in the West Bank (excluding East Jerusalem) as a single, monolithic block of religious zealots. That's completely inaccurate. If you actually walk through different communities, you'll find stark demographic and political divides that dictate how people vote.

1. The Ideological National-Religious Core
Communities like Beit El, Eli, and Yitzhar are heavily populated by national-religious families who view settling the land as a divine mandate. This is Smotrich's natural base. Voter turnout here routinely exceeds 80 percent, far higher than the national average in Tel Aviv or Haifa. These voters care deeply about cabinet portfolios—specifically the Finance Ministry and the Defense Ministry's civil administration, which controls permits, zoning, and land registration in Area C of the West Bank.

2. The Ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) Suburbs
A massive chunk of the West Bank population isn't national-religious at all. Cities like Modi'in Illit and Beitar Illit are overwhelmingly Haredi. People moved there largely because housing inside the Green Line became unaffordable for large families. On election day, these residents don't vote for Smotrich or Netanyahu. They follow the directives of their rabbis and vote overwhelmingly for Haredi parties like United Torah Judaism (UTJ) and Shas. While those parties sit in right-wing coalitions, their primary focus is yeshiva funding, military draft exemptions, and welfare budgets—not territorial maximalism.

3. Quality-of-Life Secular and Traditional Commuters
Cities like Ariel and Ma'ale Adumim function largely as bedroom communities for Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. Residents here historically leaned toward Likud or even center-right parties. Many moved for cheap mortgages and bigger backyards rather than biblical prophecy. However, even in these secular strongholds, security anxieties have pushed a noticeable slice of voters toward Ben-Gvir's populist law-and-order platform.

Understanding these three distinct groups explains why election day maps in the West Bank look fragmented rather than uniform. Yet across all three, Likud's traditional dominance has steadily bled support to its right flank.

The Bureaucratic Revolution Already Underway

This shift at the ballot box isn't just symbolic. It has fundamentally altered how the Israeli government operates on the ground.

When Netanyahu needed Smotrich and Ben-Gvir to form a government after the November 2022 elections, he couldn't just hand them ceremonial titles. They demanded—and got—structural control over the levers of power in the West Bank. Smotrich secured a dual role as Finance Minister and a second minister inside the Defense Ministry, giving him authority over the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) and the Civil Administration.

Think about what that means in practice.

Previously, military generals ran the Civil Administration. Generals tend to prioritize quiet, coordination with Palestinian security forces, and avoiding international friction. By transferring key civilian powers—like approving building plans, connecting outposts to the electrical grid, and declaring state land—from military officers to civilian bureaucrats answering directly to Smotrich, the far right bypassed the traditional checks and balances of the Israeli defense establishment.

Roads get paved faster. Master plans get approved in record numbers. Legalization processes for previously unauthorized outposts move forward without waiting for political green lights from the Prime Minister's Office.

For settler activists, this is the real victory. They realized that owning the prime minister's chair matters far less than owning the planning committees and the budget lines.

Why Netanyahu Can't Easily Win Them Back

Netanyahu is a master political survivor, and he has spent years trying to cannibalize votes from parties to his right during the final weeks of election campaigns. His classic move is the "gevalt" campaign—warning right-wing voters that if they don't vote Likud, the left will take power and establish a Palestinian state.

That tactic has lost its bite.

First, the Israeli center-left has shrunk dramatically over the last two decades, making the threat of a left-wing government hard to sell to skeptical right-wing voters. Second, voters know that under Israel's proportional representation system, Smotrich and Ben-Gvir aren't going to join a left-wing coalition anyway. Voting for them doesn't waste a right-wing seat; it just forces Netanyahu to govern further to the right once the coalition negotiations begin.

In other words, settler voters figured out the math. Giving their vote to Likud gives Netanyahu flexibility to pivot toward the center or bow to international diplomats. Giving their vote to Religious Zionism or Otzma Yehudit locks him into a rigid ideological corner.

The Geopolitical Blowback Nobody Can Ignore

Of course, this rightward march doesn't happen in a vacuum. As settlers look past Netanyahu to the far right, Israel's diplomatic standing takes a direct hit.

Western allies, including the United States and European Union members, have increasingly moved beyond boilerplate statements of "deep concern." We've seen targeted sanctions placed on individual extremist settlers, violent outpost leaders, and even organizations accused of undermining stability in the West Bank. Washington has repeatedly clashed with Smotrich over the withholding of Palestinian tax revenues and rapid settlement expansion.

Domestically, the friction is just as intense. Senior commanders in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the Shin Bet internal security agency have repeatedly warned that unchecked outpost expansion and nationalist violence divert critical troops away from other volatile fronts and inflame tensions across the region.

To mainstream Israelis living in Tel Aviv or Haifa, the rising clout of Smotrich and Ben-Gvir represents a profound shift in the country's identity—one that prioritizes territorial control over democratic norms and international alliances. To the voters in Kedumim, Hebron, and Yitzhar, that international backlash is simply proof that their representatives are finally refusing to back down.

Tracking the Real Indicators on Election Day

If you're watching Israeli election returns and want to cut through the pundit noise, stop looking solely at national polling averages and watch three specific metrics instead.

  • Turnout in national-religious settlements versus secular cities. Because Israel uses a single nationwide electoral district, high turnout in ideological communities punches way above its demographic weight. If settlements cross the 80 percent turnout threshold while Tel Aviv hovers around 60 percent, the far right gains extra Knesset seats automatically.
  • The split between Religious Zionism and Otzma Yehudit. Pay attention to whether Smotrich and Ben-Gvir run on a joint slate or separately. When they run together, they safely clear the 3.25 percent electoral threshold and maximize right-wing seats. When they split, personality clashes and competition for the exact same pool of angry voters can backfire.
  • Likud's bleed in traditional strongholds. Look at precinct results in places like Ariel, Kiryat Arba, and Ma'ale Adumim. Every percentage point Likud drops in these towns directly measures how much credibility Netanyahu has lost on core security and settlement issues.

The era where Benjamin Netanyahu could take the settler vote for granted is over. He built the political ecosystem that legitimized the far right, brought them into the mainstream, and handed them the keys to the government. Now, those very voters have decided they don't need the middleman anymore.

EW

Ethan Watson

Ethan Watson is an award-winning writer whose work has appeared in leading publications. Specializes in data-driven journalism and investigative reporting.