The fluorescent lights in the Jerusalem café hummed with a low, persistent vibration that seemed to settle right behind my eyes. Across the small wooden table sat Avi, a retired high school civics teacher whose hands shook slightly—not from age, though he was seventy-two, but from a quiet, simmering exhaustion.
"I taught them how to read a ballot," Avi said, staring into a lukewarm cup of black coffee. "I taught them that arguments are about policy. Budgets. Borders. Courts. Now, my own nephew tells me that if I question the Prime Minister, I am an enemy of the state." Read more on a connected subject: this related article.
Avi is a composite character, a hypothetical stand-in for thousands of ordinary citizens who have watched the public square transform over the last decade. Yet the fracture sitting at his kitchen table is entirely real. When political rhetoric shifts from debating ideas to questioning the fundamental loyalty of opponents, the damage does not stay inside the walls of parliament. It leaks into living rooms, workplaces, and family dinners.
In recent years, critics, opposition leaders, and former allies of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have leveled a sharp, recurring accusation against him. According to opposition figures like Yair Lapid and Benny Gantz, alongside former security chiefs and political commentators, Netanyahu has increasingly relied on aggressive personal attacks and "smear tactics" against state institutions, the judiciary, the press, and political rivals in order to maintain his grip on power. Supporters of the Prime Minister, conversely, argue that he is pushing back against an entrenched, unelected elite—including hostile media outlets and an overreaching legal establishment—that has sought to unseat a democratically elected leader for years. Further reporting by TIME explores comparable views on this issue.
Strip away the partisan shouting, and you are left with a profound question about how modern democracies function under extreme pressure. What happens to a society when political survival becomes indistinguishable from national survival?
The Architecture of a Divided Room
To understand how we arrived at a moment where political disagreements feel like existential warfare, consider the mechanics of modern political communication.
Think of a democratic society like a suspension bridge. The cables holding it up are not made of steel; they are made of institutional trust. The courts, the civil service, the free press, and the electoral system each carry a share of the weight. Citizens do not have to like the people running those institutions, nor do they have to agree with every ruling or headline. They simply have to believe that the structure itself is sound enough to hold everyone safely, regardless of who wins the next election.
Now, imagine what happens when a leader tells the public that the cables themselves are rigged.
According to political analysts and historians who have tracked Netanyahu’s long career—he is the longest-serving prime minister in Israel's history—his communication strategy has evolved alongside the rise of social media and polarized television news. During his early years in politics in the 1990s, Netanyahu was widely recognized even by detractors as a disciplined, media-savvy conservative who focused heavily on economic liberalization and security doctrine.
Over time, however, particularly following the launch of corruption investigations against him in 2016 and his subsequent indictment on charges of bribery, fraud, and breach of trust in 2019—charges he vehemently denies—critics say the tone changed fundamentally.
Former Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency) directors, ex-IDF chiefs of staff, and longtime Likud party veterans have publicly stated that the rhetoric emanating from the Prime Minister’s inner circle shifted toward delegitimizing anyone who stood in the way. Journalists were labeled "propagandists." Judges and prosecutors were accused by Netanyahu and his allies of orchestrating an "attempted political coup." Political opponents were routinely framed not merely as wrong, but as dangerous to the country's survival.
Words matter.
When a sitting prime minister uses the bully pulpit to cast state institutions as adversaries of the people, the effect is immediate. Public trust surveys conducted by the Israel Democracy Institute over the past several years have documented a steady decline in public confidence across nearly every major institution, from the Supreme Court to the police and the Knesset.
Two Realities, One Country
To be fair—and intellectual honesty demands looking closely at both sides of this divide—the frustration tapped into by Netanyahu’s camp did not materialize out of thin air.
Spend an afternoon talking to working-class voters in peripheral towns like Beersheba or Kiryat Shmona, and a very different narrative emerges. For decades, many Israelis from Mizrahi (Middle Eastern and North African) backgrounds, religious communities, and outer-ring cities felt overlooked by the traditional secular, Ashkenazi establishment that founded the state and dominated its courts, universities, and newsrooms.
To many of Netanyahu’s loyal supporters, the accusations of "smear tactics" ring hollow because they believe the establishment spent years smearing him first. From their perspective, when Netanyahu attacks the media or questions the motives of legal officials, he is not attacking democracy; he is defending the will of the voters against institutions that never respected them in the first place. Likud ministers and pro-Netanyahu commentators frequently argue that the term "smear" is applied selectively—used to condemn right-wing populism while excusing harsh personal attacks directed at the Prime Minister and his family.
This is what makes the situation so combustible. Both sides see themselves as the true defenders of democracy. Both sides believe the other is dismantling the rules of the game.
When two groups operate from entirely incompatible premises, compromise stops looking like statesmanship and starts looking like surrender.
The Human Toll of the Permanent Campaign
Let us return to the human level, because politics is never merely an abstract chess match played in television studios.
Consider a hypothetical scenario that mirrors the documented experiences of dozens of Israeli civil servants and local officials over the last few years. Imagine a mid-level municipal director—let us call her Maya—whose job is to coordinate emergency infrastructure funding between local councils and national ministries. Maya has no party affiliation. She votes differently depending on the election. Her loyalty is to the water pipes, the school roofs, and the municipal budget.
One afternoon, a routine audit from her office reveals a delay in funds promised by a government ministry. The local press picks up the story. Within hours, Maya’s name appears on partisan social media accounts, amplified by political operatives. She is accused of sabotaging the government on behalf of the opposition. Her phone lights up with messages from strangers calling her a traitor. Her superiors quietly advise her to keep her head down and avoid signing off on future audits that might look politically inconvenient.
Nothing illegal happened to Maya. No law was broken. Yet the chilling effect is total.
Political scientists refer to this phenomenon as institutional hollowing. You do not need to abolish a democracy to weaken it; you only need to make the people who keep it running afraid to do their jobs honestly. When critics accuse Netanyahu of using "ugly" tactics to cling to power, they are pointing precisely to this mechanism—a political environment where loyalty to a single leader outweighs professional integrity, and where public shaming is used to neutralize dissent before it can gain traction.
At the same time, supporters of the Prime Minister point out that political hardball is hardly unique to Israel or to Netanyahu. Across Western democracies, from Washington to London and Rome, leaders have increasingly adopted populist communication styles that bypass traditional media gatekeepers and appeal directly to voter grievances. In an era of algorithmic outrage, nuance rarely wins elections. Sharp, emotionally charged messaging does.
Why the Stakes Go Beyond One Leader
It is tempting to view this entire conflict through the lens of a single personality. Benjamin Netanyahu is undeniably a towering, polarizing figure whose political instincts have shaped Middle Eastern politics for nearly three decades. Even his fiercest critics acknowledge his formidable intellect, oratorical skill, and resilience.
Yet focusing exclusively on one man misses the deeper structural pattern.
History shows that once a political system normalizes personal vilification as a primary tool of governance, that tool does not disappear when the leader eventually leaves the stage. Every faction learns the same lesson: if outrage works, use more of it. If questioning an opponent’s patriotism wins votes, make it the centerpiece of the next campaign.
I remember standing near a protest barricade in central Tel Aviv on a humid Saturday night, watching two crowds separated by metal fencing and a line of exhausted police officers. On one side, demonstrators waved blue-and-white flags, chanting about the rule of law and demanding accountability from the government. On the other side, counter-protesters waved identical blue-and-white flags, shouting through megaphones that the crowd across the street was trying to steal their votes.
The air smelled of sweat, exhaust fumes, and warm asphalt. What struck me most was not the anger—anger is loud, predictable, and easy to photograph. It was the grief etched onto the faces of older people on both sides of the barricade. They were looking across ten feet of pavement at neighbors who spoke the same language, shared the same history, and feared the exact same future, yet could no longer hear a single word the other was saying.
That is the invisible cost of a politics built on personal destruction. Elections are supposed to settle arguments temporarily so a country can get back to the business of living together. When campaigns become endless wars of character assassination, the election never truly ends, and nobody ever really wins.
Back in that quiet Jerusalem café, Avi finally pushed his empty cup aside and looked out the window toward the street, where a young mother was struggling to fold a stroller while holding a toddler’s hand.
"You know what scares me most?" Avi asked softly, his voice barely rising above the hiss of the espresso machine. "It isn't that we disagree about who should lead us. We have disagreed since the day this country was born. What scares me is that we are teaching our children that anyone who disagrees with them isn't just wrong—they're evil. And once you believe that, there is nothing left to talk about."