Every time the state straps someone to a gurney, a predictable machine whirs into motion. Tabloids scramble for the most lurid adjectives. Reporters who claim to hold the line for public accountability line up to witness the machinery of death, breathlessly filing dispatch after dispatch detailing every twitch, gasp, and chemical burn. The narrative is always packaged the same way: a voyeuristic horror show designed to elicit maximum visceral shock, wrapped in the hollow pretense of bearing witness to justice.
Stop pretending this is journalism. It is a snuff film distributed in print, and society eats it up because we prefer our state-sponsored violence dressed in legal formalities.
When Christa Pike's execution or any other high-profile capital punishment makes headlines, the public discourse immediately spirals into a lazy, predictable binary. On one side, you have the absolute retentionists cheering for blood, viewing the procedure through a lens of raw vengeance. On the other, you have the abolitionists pointing to the mechanical failures, the botched veins, the gasping breaths, and the pharmacological cocktails as proof of state cruelty. Both sides are playing into the exact trap the system sets for them.
Focusing on whether an execution is "botched" accepts the premise that there is a clean, ethical way for the government to terminate a human life.
There is not.
I have spent years watching the criminal justice apparatus function from the inside. I have seen millions of dollars poured into legal theatrics, endless appeals, and specialized execution protocols—resources that could have been directed toward actual systemic stabilization or victim support. The obsession with the mechanics of execution is a convenient distraction. It allows society to debate the efficiency of the needle or the chair while completely avoiding the moral rot at the core of the institution itself.
The media loves a botched execution because it sells copy. Words like "botched" imply that if the drugs had flowed smoothly, if the technician had found the vein on the first try, and if the inmate had slipped away quietly in their sleep, the act would somehow be acceptable. That is the lie. A successful execution is just as morally bankrupt as a messy one; it is simply better sanitized for our collective conscience.
Consider the common questions that flood search engines after every major execution. People want to know what the inmate said last, how long it took for them to die, and what physical reactions occurred behind the glass. These are the queries of a culture addicted to true-crime entertainment, treating state-sanctioned homicide as a late-night streaming thriller. The premise of these questions is fundamentally flawed. They ask how it happened, when we should be asking why we continue to participate in this barbaric theater.
The defenders of capital punishment argue that it brings closure. It does not. It extends the trauma, creating a multi-decade circus that keeps victims' families trapped in a loop of anticipation and media saturation. Meanwhile, the state hides behind closed doors, wielding lethal chemicals behind institutional walls while claiming to act on behalf of the public.
If we are going to talk about capital punishment, let us strip away the gothic romanticism of the death chamber. Let us stop treating the physical symptoms of lethal injection as medical anomalies or administrative errors. They are the predictable outcome of asking human beings to play executioner under the guise of medicine.
The contrarian truth is simple: making executions more efficient does not make them more civilized. It only makes us more complicit. Stop reading the play-by-plays. Stop treating the death chamber like a stage. The only ethical stance left is to reject the spectacle entirely.